While every grief is different, as unique to your relationship with the person gone, as grief expert David Kessler says, "Your grief is always the biggest grief, because it is yours."
Common and Lesser-Known Symptoms of Grief
First, it helps to know what’s “normal.” Megan Devine writes in her grief journal book How to Carry What Can’t Be Fixed:
“Because we don't usually talk about the realities of grief, most people aren't aware of the many forms grief takes. While your 'symptoms' might feel weird, you're probably not alone in experiencing them. Normal grief covers a lot of territory.
Even if you've lived through grief at other times in your life, you've never had to live this particular story before. Your grief might show up in interesting or confusing ways.”
Devine offers this list of symptoms you and/or your loved ones may be experiencing.
"You either go under, or it changes you, or, worse, you become a small, hard thing that has contracted around an absence.
Sometimes you find a grieving person constricted around the thing they have lost; they've become ossified and impossible to penetrate, and, well, other people go the other way, and grow open and expansive.”
- Nick Cave
The Choice in Grief: Close Off or Break Open
Nick Cave on grief:
“I think there's a decision that we need to make…I mean this is not particular to me—this is ordinary stuff on some level that everyone goes through eventually, in one way or another. We all go through these sorts of things, and we have a choice, I think.
There is on some level a desire to turn inward and to sort of wrap ourselves around the absence of the person that we've lost…as if there's some sort of nobility in wrapping ourselves around the absence of that person, and I think this is a very dangerous situation and a mistake, and that we must be able to turn ourselves the other way and look at the world and understand that we are part of the world and that the world is essentially full of people who have lost things."
"You reconcile yourself to the acute jeopardy of life, and you do this by acknowledging the value in things, the precious nature of things, and savoring the time we have together in this world. You learn that the binding agent of the world is love."
Marie Howe: "At every opportunity, we have a chance to either open to it or close to it. And the great thing about art is that art helps us to let our hearts break open, rather than close.
Everybody has known unimaginable moments of loneliness. Everyone we know has known pain and fear. And yet art can help us open to those moments rather than shut to those moments. So writing poetry and reading poetry has been a way of experiencing life so that everything can be contained in the human heart. Nothing is excluded."
Find poems to walk with you through grief, here.
So how to turn outward?
If you can encourage yourself to look, you find out you are in a terrible kinship
with everyone who has ever borne losses.
You find out that while your grief is as unique as your person's voice,
the love that binds you together, is the same force that binds us all together.
But in acute, new grief—it's ok if this doesn't happen right away. Keep trying to break open, not close inward.
Sometimes everything is edged in light, and you cling to everything dear to you.
Sometimes, you're hurting too much to be able to see anything clearly, and you need time alone.
It's OK that you're not OK.
It takes time to metabolize the enormity of grief.
Understanding Grief Through Metaphor
How to Support Others in Grief
A beautiful illustration and article for how to manage your own pain and also care for the people at the center of the struggle.
3-minute animated video where Brene Brown explains simply and beautifully the difference between sympathy and empathy.
This 3-minute animated video by Refuge in Grief talks about what actually helps those who are hurting and/or experiencing any type of pain or loss. It may seem so unforgivingly minimal, but offering acknowledgment without trying to shapeshift their pain is the best medicine.
Click the boxes below to learn more tips on what actually helps and what hurts.
And this graphic on many ways to care for and feed those grieving. This isn't limited to death, but any loss.
On Losing Someone to Suicide: whether sudden or slow (click to expand)
It's ok to feel angry, to be confused, to be shattered, to feel enormous guilt. All of this is normal in coping with the loss of a loved one to suicide. You can find resources specific to children coping with suicide loss in the above Children Resources section.
⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦
Crisis Connections will send a book and care package and offer support if you share your mailing address. They can also match with you with peer survivors who have walked the path of similar losses.
The book Crisis Connections sends survivors is called: After Suicide Loss: Coping With Your Grief by Jack Jordan Ph.D. & Bob Baugher Ph.D.
Excerpts:
Be aware that when people are acutely suicidal, they are almost always in an altered state of consciousness, and their thinking and emotions are not normal.
We need to make every effort to provide effective help to anyone who is suicidal. But society also needs to recognize that not every suicide can be prevented, in spite of our best efforts.
...
It follows that if suicide is the perfect storm of the wrong things happening, then perhaps we can say that suicide prevention is the perfect rainbow of the right things happening. The individual who is suicidal must communicate their distress and intentions in some recognizable way - unfortunately, this is often done obliquely, making statements like "I won't be a burden much longer." Then, the people around the suicidal individual must recognize and react appropriately to the warning signs that someone is contemplating a suicide attempt. After that, the necessary support and professional services must be readily available, not just for the immediate crisis, but to provide longer term follow-up so that the distressed individual receives the competent care that is necessary.
Unfortunately, there is considerable evidence that suicidal individuals are often "under-treated" for their psychiatric disorders, social distress, and suicidality — the mental health care system in the United States is frequently deficient in the quantity and quality of services that it provides for suicidal individuals.
And lastly, the person who is suicidal has to be able to hold on to the part of themselves that wants to live. We know that most people who take their life are ambivalent about dying, but they have reached a point where they perceive that all of their other options have been exhausted, and that only suicide can solve their problems and resolve their distress. Thus, when all of the elements in the "perfect rainbow" of protective conditions are present, then suicide can indeed be prevented. Tragically, this does not happen often enough. Suicide prevention efforts in our country must be improved so that help is available when and where people need it, and the public understands and responds appropriately to distress signals from someone who is thinking of ending their life.
So, could the suicide of your loved one have been prevented?
We know that this question often haunts many survivors for a long time. What we can tell you is that while some suicides can be prevented, it is rarely within the power of just one person to prevent a suicide - instead, it takes the collective efforts of mental health professionals, family and friends, and yes, the suicidal person themselves, to keep it from happening. Come back to this fact again and again as you work to understand the suicide of your loved one.
Video: Click here: What to do with the "What Ifs" by David Kessler
Grief expert David Kessler writes in Finding Meaning: The Sixth Stage of Grief (note: he means meaning in your life, not the loss):
“One of the first things I say to such people is that when someone is intent on harming themselves, we may be powerless to prevent it. We should always try, but we cannot blame ourselves after the fact. Suicide is often an impulsive act, undertaken in a moment of despair. It can happen after years of psychotherapy, antidepressants, hospitalizations, and even shock therapy. Several recent celebrity deaths have driven that point home.
Still, our mind defaults to the if-onlys. My friend Vivian called me recently after her seventy-year-old father died by suicide. An untreated alcoholic, he had been threatening to do it for years, and it seemed inevitable that someday he would. But Vivian couldn't stop thinking, "If only I had gone to his house that day," "If only I'd made him see another doctor," "If only I'd intervened in his alcoholism."
Such thoughts are a product of guilt, but they are also the mind's way of trying to assert control in an uncontrollable situation that has already happened.
Death by suicide is not a selfish act or even a choice. It's a sign of a mind that needs help. It's a horrific outcome to a tragic situation. We know from countless people who have survived a suicide attempt that they weren't looking to die.
They felt they just couldn't continue to live in so much pain.
Some suicides are driven by external circumstances--people are in overwhelming debt or they've lost the person they most loved or they have a serious chronic illness, or legal issues or substance abuse problems. But many who died by suicide lived lives that can only be described as ideal, at least from the outside. They had families and friends who loved them, plenty of money, beautiful homes, professional success, yet they were tormented. Why? I think that for those of us without suicidal tendencies, it is almost impossible to imagine what it's like for those who do have them. Clinical depression itself is a serious illness, which can lead to suicide.
...
Just as we know too little about what causes suicide, our knowledge of how to prevent it is also limited. People say to me, "No, no, you don't understand. I helped him once and I should have been there to do it again," or "I actually could've prevented it if only I'd known." I share the following reality with them:
Consider This
New hospitals are being built with mental health units designed by specialized architects and firms. Among the most crucial considerations in the construction of these facilities is how to prevent death by suicide. Enormous amounts of thought have gone into the design of everything from the doors and even the door hinges to the bathroom fixtures, the lighting, the cabinets and drawers, and the windows with shatter-resistant glass. Once the hospitals are built, they are staffed by psychiatrists, psychiatric nurses, and technicians trained to prevent death by suicide. And yet, despite all the care taken with design, the specialized staffing, the inspections of all personal items, the constant surveillance that deprives patients of their privacy, a few people in these institutions will still die by suicide.
I gently tell those who are still feeling so much guilt, replaying their if-onlys, "Maybe you could've done something in that moment, but if they were intent on ending their lives, if their minds were in that much pain, you have to understand that they would have found another moment when you weren't there." They need to stop blaming themselves—and stop blaming the person who died."
⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦
Excerpt from an article by Rachel Zimmerman:
"The vast majority of suicides involve people with some manner of mental illness; major depression, bipolar or substance-abuse disorder is often at play. Sometimes, there’s no clear-cut diagnosis, just a deep psychological conflict that turns deadly. My husband was never diagnosed with any serious mental illness, but I am sure that illness — possibly undiagnosed bipolar, certainly escalating anxiety and depression he’d masterfully hidden — was the cause of his death.
Daniel Brenner, a Cambridge-based psychiatrist and psychoanalyst (and a high school classmate of mine) told me that self-harm, sometimes irreversible, can be a “symptom” of this type of disease. “It’s not anyone’s choice,” Brenner said. “It’s outside the realm of choice, like a fatal heart attack.” He added: “There are behaviors that look like choices that don't take into account how biologically determined they are.”
Moreover, he said, suicide remains so incomprehensible, there’s a tendency to view it as a personal failure, the ultimate selfish act, a refusal to fight for life. “It’s kind of like saying someone in a burning building is a failure because they jumped," he said. "We’re talking about a kind of suffering that is, for the most part, outside the realm of anyone else’s experience.”
⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦
So much remains a mystery inside a person's heart and mind.
When your mind is trying so hard to make sense of it all, or replay things, or want things to be different, sometimes you can only remind yourself to come back to the present and remember how much isn't yours to know.
Excerpts from A River Runs Through It and Other Stories by Norman Maclean:
"Help," he said, "is giving part of yourself to somebody who comes to accept it willingly and needs it badly."
"So it is," he said, "that we can seldom help anybody. Either we don't know what part to give or maybe we don't like to give any part of ourselves. Then, more often than not, the part that is needed is not wanted. And even more often, we do not have the part that is needed...But we can still love them - we can love completely without complete understanding."
Video: Thich Nhat Hanh on how to deal with suicide in a family.
You can call, text, or chat with 988, the crisis line. 988 is not only for those in crisis. But if you are in crisis, please reach out.
"Whether you're facing mental health struggles, emotional distress, alcohol or drug use concerns, or just need someone to talk to, our caring counselors are here for you. You are not alone."
Talk therapy and journaling are medicine. Maybe the most important kind.
Getting the narrative out into language and sharing the weight of our feelings with others is so important.
Ask your friends and family to help you find a therapist who can listen to you. Join grief groups, journal. And most of all, permit yourself to speak of this loss. You will begin to find the words and the words will find you.
“Anything that's human is mentionable, and anything that is mentionable can be more manageable.
When we can talk about our feelings, they become less overwhelming, less upsetting, and less scary. The people we trust with that important talk can help us know that we are not alone.”
- Fred Rogers
"All sorrows can be borne if you put them into a story or tell a story about them."
-Isak Dinesen
Your Feet Will Touch Ground
David Whyte on grief:
"But when he went, it was like the other half of me disappeared. And we have this physical experience in loss, of falling toward something. So it’s like falling in love, except it’s falling into grief. And you’re falling towards the foundation that they held for you in your life that you didn’t realize they were holding. And you fall and fall and fall, and you don’t find it for the longest time. And so the shock of the loss to begin with, and the hermetic sealing off, is necessary in grief.
But then there comes a time where you finally, actually start to touch the ground that they were holding for you, and it’s from that ground that you step off into your new life. And been very strange phenomena in that instance — for instance, of losing John, whereby I’ll start a sentence and feel like John has finished it. Or I’ll hear John speaking, and I’ll start in his voice and finish in my own. And sometimes we’re both talking together, which happened a lot when we were actually together.
And so there’s this really astonishing melding that occurs, which is a kind of dream time, which human beings start to move into in their maturity, actually, where what is past, what is present, and what’s about to occur are not so clearly marked out.
One of the things the Irish say is that the thing about the past is it’s not the past. It’s right here, in this room, in this conversation.
Forever Twinned
The depth of your grief is the depth of your love. They are equal and inverse. It's all part of the same thing.
"It seems to me that if we love, we grieve. That’s the deal. That’s the pact. Grief and love are forever intertwined. Grief is the terrible reminder of the depths of our love and, like love, grief is non-negotiable. There is a vastness to grief that overwhelms our minuscule selves. We are tiny, trembling clusters of atoms subsumed within grief’s awesome presence." - Nick Cave
A Note on Complicated Relationships:
Grief is one of the ways we love. It is a painful expression of love. And we also know that grief isn't only love. If you've had a complicated or traumatic history with the person who has died or you are separated from, your feelings will be complicated, too. Be very gentle and accepting of yourself now. Your history with this person may include love, hurt, and even harm. Grief is a lot like a mirror into our relationship with the person.
Feelings: Indicator Lights
In grief, a huge array of thoughts and feelings come up that we have no control over. We only have control over our response.
Befriending yourself and greeting your thoughts and feelings as messengers in transit is one of the most helpful things we can do to not add to our suffering. We can so easily get into conversations and struggles with ourselves about our thoughts and feelings, and we push against them.
If we can try to be gentle with them, the pain can become less complicated.
If you're able to view your feelings not as facts but as indicator lights, it can help so much, and then you can ask them gently:
Where does it hurt?
What is the fear here?
What is important to you?
What would help right now?
Emotions Can't Cancel Each Other Out
There are no incorrect feelings. They offer us information. And feelings don't cancel each other out. We can contain anger and sadness, regret and relief, love and confusion — all at once. Our wingspan can touch life's sweetness on one side and all its pain on the other. All of it belongs within us.
When an unwelcome feeling comes up, you may try saying, "Yes, this too." or "This belongs."
So try adding an "and" to every wave that comes up—your heart can hold it all. All the truths and disappointments and heartaches and history.
See how that feels in your body — to let the pain and paradoxes be there.
It may be painful, and yet we suffer less when we say "and."
Help for How to Practice "and":
How to feel less pain by staying with your body. (from time-stamp 53:56)
Elizabeth Gilbert on How to Move Through Grief as Grief Moves Through You
A Note on Numbness:
It's also important to know that in addition to feeling the whole spectrum of emotions in grief, from anger to sadness to regret or guilt or confusion, it's also completely normal to feel numb as your brain helps you take breaks from the strain of it all. It can be disorienting and worrisome to feel numb, but just like all things and all feelings, it is impermanent. It does not reflect the depth of your care. Sometimes, all we can do is say hello to that numbness. It will pass. You will feel again.
Books on Grief:
David Kessler: Finding Meaning (this is talking about making meaning in your life, not in what happened.)
Thich Nhat Hanh: How to Live When a Loved One Dies (if your relationship was not tender, this book also talks about difficult relationships, too.)
Megan Devine: It's OK That You're Not OK
Megan Devine: How to Carry What Can't Be Fixed, A Grief Journal
After Suicide Loss: Coping With Your Grief by Jack Jordan Ph.D. & Bob Baugher Ph.D.
Nick Cave and Seán O' Hagen: Faith, Hope & Carnage
⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦
Other Resources:
Follow David Kessler and find his very helpful website grief.com
Follow: Megan Devine's Facebook page, Refuge in Grief. She also has an Instagram if you prefer that. Her website refugeingrief.com is full of helpful support.
Learn the myths of self-compassion and how it makes you more resilient, on Kristin Neff's site self-compassion.org
⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦⏦
Other Books on Emotions & Being Human:
(There are Brene Brown podcast interviews with all 3 of the above authors, which is how I discovered them.)
A Blessing
May you walk slowly.
May you be gentle with yourself.
May the ocean of your love
be a vessel for your grief
and wash the sharp edges,
turning and turning them
to soft stones
you can carry.